Ahn E, Choi G, Kang H, Baek C, Jung Y, Woo Y, Bang S. PLoS One. 2018 Nov 5;13(11):e0206804
This network meta-analysis (with a mixed-treatment comparison method to combine direct and indirect comparisons) compared the effectiveness of seven different SADs as a strategy for unassisted tracheal intubation. The primary outcome was the overall success rate of intubation by intention to treat (ITT) and the secondary outcomes included the overall tracheal intubation success rate (per protocol - PP) and the success rate of tracheal intubation at first attempt by ITT and PP.
Link to abstract.
Tags :
2018,
Ahn E,
PLoS One,
Meta-analysis,
Tracheal intubation,
unassisted tracheal intubation,
intention to treat,
direct tracheal intubation,
indirect tracheal intubation,
vs LMA CTrach,
vs LMA Fastrach,
vs air-Q,
vs Cobra,
vs Ambu Aura,
single-use
2c73ba99-33c1-4f52-80fb-5cd028d19507|1|1.0|27604f05-86ad-47ef-9e05-950bb762570c
Kim JG, Kim W, Kang GH, Jang YS, Choi HY, Kim H, Kim M. Clin Exp Emerg Med. 2018 Mar 30;5(1):29-34.
This prospective randomised crossover study was carried out to evaluate the performance and efficacy of the i-gel blind intubation (IGI) in airway management for pre-hospital trauma patients. Here, two blind intubation techniques were assessed (by 18 paramedics) using two supraglottic airway devices (IGI and LMA Fastrach) and a Macintosh laryngoscope (MCL).
Link to abstract.
Tags :
2018,
Clin Exp Emerg Med,
Kim JG,
Randomised cross over study,
RCT,
Airway management,
Paramedics,
pre-hospital,
emergency care,
Emergency medicine,
Trauma ,
blind intubation,
vs LMA Fastrach,
vs Macintosh laryngoscope
1fdd4b36-656e-4ca7-b567-60eb07b84ab0|1|3.0|27604f05-86ad-47ef-9e05-950bb762570c
An J, Nam SB, Lee JS, Lee J, Yoo H, Lee HM, Kim MS. Medicine (Baltimore). 2017 Jan;96(1):e5801
Authors conducted a specialised search of study databases for eligible randomised controlled trials, setting device insertion time and first-attempt insertion success rate as their primary outcomes. In the 14 RCTs included, i-gel was faster than the majority of other supraglottic airways, with only three others recording shorter insertion times. Authors concluded that the 'unapparent advantage' of insertion success rate indicated the need for further evidence gathering in this area.
Link to abstract.
Tags :
2017,
An J,
Medicine (Baltimore),
RCTs,
Meta-analysis,
Review,
Insertion success rate,
Fast insertion time,
vs LMA,
vs LMA Fastrach,
vs ProSeal,
vs LMA Unique,
vs Laryngeal tube ,
vs Combitube,
vs EasyTube,
vs LMA Supreme,
vs aura-i,
vs air-Q,
Manikin study
3078c3a6-ac94-4115-834b-506513077209|1|1.0|27604f05-86ad-47ef-9e05-950bb762570c
Moore A, Gregoire-Bertrand F, Massicotte N, Gauthier A, Lallo A, Ruel M, Todorov A, Girard F. Anesth Analg. 2015 Aug;121(2):430-6
120 patients were randomly assigned to i-gel or LMA Fastrach groups, with tracheal intubation and mask insertion success rate measured. Use of i-gel as a conduit in this scenario is equivalent to Fastrach, however gives shorter intubation times and a better visualisation of the glottic opening.
Link to abstract
ec6c9755-9023-49e6-8a0e-1b26b42bf274|1|5.0|27604f05-86ad-47ef-9e05-950bb762570c
Kapoor S, Jethava DD, Gupta P, Jethava D, Kumar A. Indian J Anaesth. 2014 Jul;58(4):397-402.
Two randomised groups were assigned either device and after insertion, blind tracheal intubation was attempted. Success at first attempt and overall intubation success rates were assessed. Authors concluded that the i-gel is 'a better device' for rescue ventilation.
Link to abstract.
a86f6579-d062-48ff-b621-4c039bfbf6bd|1|3.0|27604f05-86ad-47ef-9e05-950bb762570c